I am going to divide this review into two sections: foam Balls and Plastic Balls
In the interest of testing “quiet” technology, I have begun testing foam and other quiet balls. The reason is simple: we have our own court that is surrounded by other homes. Also, we live in the North Georgia mountains, and sound carries – really carries.

So, we decided to experiment with quiet balls, both foam and polypropylene.
Of the foam ball manufacturers, these are the ones who have responded and whose balls I have tested: Tourna Whisper, Diadem Quiet, and the Enhance Ninja.
These manufacturers declined to participate: Franklin, Luzz, and Gamma.
POLYPROPYLENE QUIET BALLS
The only polypropylene quiet ball I have tested so far is the Selkirk Q1 Quiet Ball. Because it is not a foam ball—and because I was particularly interested in how it would perform outdoors—I purchased the balls myself.
First, though, what exactly is polypropylene?
Polypropylene (PP) is a lightweight, durable thermoplastic identified by the #5 recycling code. You probably see it every day because it is commonly used for food containers and other packaging. It is recyclable, although not every local recycling program accepts #5 plastic. Unfortunately, ours does not.
SELKIRK Q1 BALL REVIEW
WEIGHT AND CONSTRUCTION
A regulation pickleball typically weighs between 0.78 and 0.935 ounces. The Q1 weighs about 0.86 ounces, putting it right in the range of a conventional hard-plastic pickleball. It also has the familiar 40-hole design.
Pick it up, though, and you can tell there is a difference. The Q1 feels slightly softer than a typical outdoor ball, although nowhere near as soft as an indoor ball.
There is something else that makes the Q1 particularly interesting: the Q1 Quiet Ball was the first noise-reducing pickleball approved for USA Pickleball-sanctioned competition.
That raises the obvious question: If it is quieter, does it still play like a “normal” pickleball?

HOW DOES IT PLAY?
For the most part, it plays the same as a hard plastic ball, although I do think it plays just a tad softer.
First, Selkirk says the Q1 is 34% quieter than a standard outdoor pickleball. I haven’t measured the sound level myself, so I can’t verify the 34% figure. What I can say is that the difference is noticeable. The Q1 is definitely quieter than a conventional outdoor ball.
Second, it plays remarkably like a normal pickleball. The bounce, flight, and overall feel are familiar enough that there isn’t much of an adjustment period.
I noticed this when I recently went back to playing with regular outdoor balls at our local courts. My first few shots sailed long. It took only a few minutes to adjust, but it told me that I had become accustomed to the slightly different feel of the Q1.
DURABILITY
This may be the part that has impressed me the most.
I purchased two sleeves of three balls each, and we have now been using the Q1 balls for more than a month. So far, they show no signs of cracking or going out of round.
Considering how quickly some conventional pickleballs crack, warp, or develop soft spots, that is pretty impressive.
MY TAKE
There really isn’t much more I can say about the Q1—and, in this case, that’s a compliment.
A quiet pickleball shouldn’t require you to completely change the way you play. Ideally, it should feel like a regular pickleball while making considerably less noise.
That is pretty much what the Q1 does.
It isn’t silent, and it isn’t nearly as quiet as some of the foam balls I have tested. But if you want a quieter plastic pickleball that still looks, feels, and plays very much like a conventional outdoor ball, the Selkirk Q1 Quiet Ball is where I would start.
FOAM BALLS
TOURNA WHISPERBALL FOAM PICKLEBALL REVIEW

NOTE: I did not pay for these. They were provided to me free of charge so I could review them.
The Tourna Whisperball has received considerable attention as a quiet foam alternative to a conventional pickleball. After playing with it, I can understand why.
We’ve tested several foam pickleballs, and while each has its strengths and weaknesses, the Whisperball does something particularly well:
It behaves more like a conventional plastic pickleball than any of the other foam balls we have tested.
That’s an important distinction. Making a ball quiet is relatively easy. Making it quiet while still allowing players to dink, drive, serve, spin, drop, and reset the ball in something approaching normal pickleball is much more difficult.
HERE IS WHAT TOURNA SAYS
Tourna describes the Whisperball this way:
SILENT PRACTICE ANYTIME – DAY OR NIGHT: Designed for quiet indoor or outdoor play, allowing players to practice without disturbing neighbors or other household members.
REALISTIC GAMEPLAY FEEL: Engineered to approximate the bounce, diameter, and weight of a regulation pickleball so that drills and practice sessions feel more like normal play.
HIGH VISIBILITY DESIGN: The bright yellow color makes the ball easy to track under a variety of lighting conditions.
BUILT TO LAST: Constructed from high-density foam designed to retain its shape through repeated use.
Those are the claims.
So, how does it actually play?
PERFORMANCE
“Squirrely-ness”:
The Whisperball is the least squirrely foam ball we have tested.
All foam balls are susceptible to air movement. That’s simply something you have to accept when playing with them outdoors. Even relatively light wind can cause a foam ball to move unexpectedly.
The Whisperball does it less.
I suspect its weight may have something to do with that. The Whisperball weighs approximately 0.9 ounces, compared with approximately 0.8 ounces for several of the other foam balls we have tested.
You may be thinking: What’s the big deal about one-tenth of an ounce?
Quite a bit, potentially.
One-tenth of an ounce is approximately 2.8 grams—or, for practical purposes, about 3 grams.
If you’re familiar with paddle customization, that number should sound familiar. Many of the snap-on or adhesive weights players use to alter paddle balance and stability are approximately 3 grams each. Players can definitely notice what a few strategically placed grams do to a paddle.
Now, that doesn’t prove the Whisperball’s extra weight is responsible for its greater stability in the air. That’s my theory based on playing with it. But the difference in flight is noticeable.
It still moves in the wind. It just doesn’t seem to get pushed around as easily as some of the lighter foam balls.
Spin:
Another pleasant surprise is that you can actually generate useful spin with the Whisperball.
I can hit topspin and sidespin with it, and both have a noticeable effect on the ball.
Topspin, in particular, works well. Unlike some foam balls where topspin can cause the ball to suddenly dive, the Whisperball’s reaction is more predictable. I can use topspin to help bring a harder shot back into the court without having the ball suddenly drop off a cliff.
I have to admit that I continue to have trouble generating meaningful underspin with any foam ball I’ve tested. The Whisperball hasn’t changed that.
But for topspin and sidespin, it performs surprisingly well.
Power:
Here’s another area where the Whisperball separates itself from some of the other foam balls we’ve tested:
You can bang it.
Within reason.
You still can’t forget that you’re hitting a foam ball. If you swing wildly and try to crush everything, the ball can fly. But I can hit the Whisperball considerably more aggressively than some other foam balls without completely changing the way I normally play.
That is particularly noticeable on serves and groundstrokes.
I don’t have to completely reinvent my serve or dramatically reduce my swing speed. I still have to make some adjustments, but they are relatively minor.
Again, it simply behaves more like a conventional plastic pickleball.
Net Play:
The Whisperball is excellent around the kitchen.
Dinks feel natural. Third-shot drops work well. Volleys are predictable. Transition-zone resets behave much the way I expect them to.
That’s important because the soft game is one area where a foam ball can be particularly useful as a training tool. If a practice ball behaves radically differently from a conventional pickleball, you can end up practicing technique that doesn’t necessarily transfer well to an actual game.
I don’t have that concern with the Whisperball.
The ball isn’t identical to a plastic pickleball, of course, but the adjustments required are small enough that the practice still feels relevant.
Feel:
At approximately 0.9 ounces, the Whisperball is near the heavier end of the weight range for conventional pickleballs, and you can feel that additional substance when the ball contacts the paddle.
I like that.
It doesn’t have the extremely light, almost toy-like sensation that some foam practice balls can have. The impact feels more substantial, which contributes to the overall impression that you’re playing pickleball rather than simply hitting a foam practice ball over a net.
Noise Reduction:
And, of course, we can’t forget the primary reason these balls exist.
The Whisperball is remarkably quiet.
That makes it particularly attractive for neighborhoods where homes are close to pickleball courts, early-morning or evening practice, indoor drilling, or any situation where the distinctive pop-pop-pop of conventional pickleballs could become a problem.
For those of us who want to play without annoying the neighbors, that’s a significant advantage.
BOTTOM LINE
For third-shot drops, dinking, volleying, transition-zone resets, serves, groundstrokes, and general control work, the Tourna Whisperball performs extremely well.
You can generate useful topspin and sidespin. You can hit the ball fairly hard without constantly sending it long. Net play feels natural. And its slightly heavier weight may help make it less susceptible to wind than some of the lighter foam balls we have tested.
Most importantly, I don’t feel as though I have to completely change the way I play pickleball when I use it.
That’s a big deal.
There is still one caveat: it’s a foam ball.
If you’re playing outdoors, wind matters. You still have to concentrate and watch the ball carefully because even the Whisperball can be affected by air currents. And if you try to absolutely kill the ball, it can fly.
But those are relatively minor compromises considering how quiet it is.
The Whisperball works very well as a practice ball, but I wouldn’t limit it to practice. In my opinion, it is good enough for competitive recreational games, particularly when noise reduction is important.
Of all the foam pickleballs we have tested so far, the Tourna Whisperball comes closest to giving us the quiet we want without requiring us to give up the way we normally play pickleball.
You can purchase the balls on Amazon: https://amzn.to/45IL3tF
***
DIADEM QUIET PICKLEBALL REVIEW
I have had these for years, using them on the indoor court in our community. As I remember, they were pretty inexpensive.

WHAT DIADEM SAYS
Here is what the Diadem website says about its Official Quiet Ball:
“Experience top-tier performance with the Diadem Sports Official Quiet Ball. Engineered with precision foam density to replicate the bounce of standard pickleballs, it ensures a familiar, reliable feel.”
Diadem lists the following key features:
- Engineered Foam Density: Designed with a specific foam density to closely mimic the weight, size, and bounce of a traditional plastic indoor or outdoor pickleball.
- Reduced Noise: Ideal for indoor use and noise-sensitive settings.
- Durable Design: Designed to withstand regular play while maintaining its performance.
- Official Size and Weight: USA Pickleball specifies a ball weight between 0.78 and 0.935 ounces. The Diadem weighs approximately 0.8 ounces, so it falls within that range.
- Playability: In my opinion, it is suitable for both recreational and surprisingly competitive play.
- Bounce: USA Pickleball specifies that a ball should bounce between 30 and 34 inches when dropped from a height of 78 inches. I didn’t get out a tape measure and conduct a formal test, but the Diadem’s bounce certainly seems comparable to that of a regulation ball.
Of course, specifications only tell you so much. The real question is: How does it play?
PERFORMANCE
Feel:
One of the first things we noticed was that the Diadem ball has a heavier feel than some of the other foam balls we have used. What’s interesting is that it weighs only about 0.8 ounces, compared with roughly 0.9 ounces for many traditional pickleballs.
So why does it feel heavier?
I’m not sure.
It could be the density of the foam, the way the ball comes off the paddle, or the way it travels through the air. Whatever the reason, the difference is noticeable. And, frankly, I like it. The added sense of substance makes it feel more like you’re hitting a pickleball and less like you’re hitting a lightweight practice ball.
“Squirrely-ness”:
Like all the foam balls we have tried, wind can make the Diadem do funny things.
As I mentioned in my other blog post about foam pickleballs, you REALLY have to concentrate when playing with them outdoors. Even a relatively small amount of wind can alter the ball’s flight more than you would expect with a conventional plastic pickleball.
That means you can’t always assume the ball is going to continue along the trajectory you expect. You have to watch it all the way to the paddle.
That isn’t necessarily a bad thing. In fact, playing with foam balls outdoors can be a pretty good concentration exercise.
Spin:
This is where the Diadem really surprised us.
For the most part, the foam balls we have tried don’t give you nearly the same ability to use spin that you get with a conventional pickleball.
Not so with the Diadem.
After we dinked for a few minutes, I tried a couple of practice serves. I hit them the way I normally hit a topspin serve—and promptly drove the ball straight into the net.
At first, I thought I had simply mishit it. So I tried again.
Same result.
The topspin was pulling the ball down much more aggressively than I expected.
Once I adjusted for that, we discovered something interesting: you can hit the Diadem surprisingly hard if you put topspin on it. I could swing aggressively, give the ball more height, and let the topspin bring it back down into the court.
That makes the Diadem much more interesting to me than a foam ball that is useful only for casual hitting.
There is a catch. The ball tends to drop quickly, so once again, you have to concentrate and adjust your normal expectations about its flight.
But the ability to actually use topspin—and to use it effectively—is a major plus.
Durability:
So far, durability has also been good.
We have been using the balls for several weeks, and they seem to be holding up quite well.
That’s important because durability has been an issue with some foam balls we have used in the past. A quiet ball isn’t much of a bargain if its playing characteristics deteriorate after a relatively short period of use.
BOTTOM LINE
We have primarily been using the Diadem Quiet Balls outdoors because our objective is to minimize pickleball noise without sacrificing the game itself.
And in that respect, they perform very well.
Are they identical to conventional plastic pickleballs? No.
Wind affects them more. They have an unusual heavier feel despite their relatively light actual weight. And they have a tendency to drop more quickly than a traditional ball.
But they also do something that I think is much more important:
They let us actually play pickleball.
We can dink with them. We can drive them. We can serve aggressively. We can use topspin. And once we adjust to their different flight characteristics, we can play competitive points rather than simply hitting a soft practice ball back and forth.
I suspect the Diadem ball would perform even better indoors, where wind is removed from the equation. I haven’t tested it enough indoors to say that definitively, however, so for now that’s an assumption rather than a conclusion.
For outdoor play in a noise-sensitive environment, though, the Diadem is one of the better foam balls we have tried.
And perhaps the best compliment I can give it is this:
After a while, you stop thinking quite so much about the fact that you’re playing with a quiet foam ball—and start thinking about the point you’re trying to win.
***
ENHANCE NINJA FOAM BALL REVIEW

HERE IS WHAT ENHANCE SAYS
These are the most expensive of the foam balls and, in my opinion, the closest to a plastic ball.
Enhance describes the Ninja Ball this way:
“With the Ninja Ball, you can play pickleball wherever you want without making any noise. The ball is made of a foam that bounces very similar to a normal pickleball. We designed the ball for practice, but if you can’t play games due to noise, it can be a great substitute.”
That description is actually pretty accurate. The Ninja is clearly designed first as a practice ball, but after playing with it for several weeks, I think it can do considerably more than that—provided you understand its limitations.
SPECIFICATIONS AND INITIAL IMPRESSIONS
Size & Weight:
The Ninja is designed to replicate the dimensions and weight of a standard pickleball. USA Pickleball specifies that a ball should weigh between 0.78 and 0.935 ounces. The Ninja weighs approximately 0.8 ounces, putting it within that range.
Interestingly, it doesn’t feel particularly light when it comes off the paddle. It has a more substantial feel than you might expect from a foam ball and, in that respect, feels surprisingly similar to a conventional plastic pickleball.
Bounce:
Enhance says the Ninja’s bounce is designed to be as close to a conventional pickleball as possible.
For dinking, volleying, resets, and similar shots, I would agree that the bounce feels reasonably natural. However, when I dropped the ball from 78 inches—the height USA Pickleball uses for its bounce test—it appeared to bounce higher than some of the other foam balls we have tested.
I didn’t conduct a laboratory measurement, so that’s an observation rather than a formal test. But the difference was noticeable.
Noise:
This, of course, is the reason the Ninja exists.
It is dramatically quieter than a conventional plastic pickleball, making it particularly useful for indoor practice, garages, private courts, and neighborhoods where pickleball noise is an issue.
Durability:
After a couple of weeks of use, the surface of our Ninja balls is beginning to show some scuffing.
So far, however, the wear appears to be cosmetic. It hasn’t noticeably changed the way the ball plays.
PERFORMANCE
“Squirrely-ness”:
Like almost every foam ball we have tried, the Ninja reacts to wind.
But it doesn’t react quite like the Diadem.
The best comparison I can make is to a knuckleball in baseball. Instead of simply drifting in one direction, the Ninja can move one way and then another as it travels through the air. Even a relatively small amount of wind can make its flight unpredictable.
That means concentration is extremely important. You really have to watch the ball all the way to your paddle.
It can be frustrating—but it can also make for some interesting points.
Spin:
This is one area where the Ninja is considerably different from the Diadem.
The Ninja has a relatively smooth foam surface, and we found it difficult to generate much spin with it. My assumption is that the smooth surface simply doesn’t give the paddle enough opportunity to grip the ball, although that’s my deduction rather than something I have scientifically tested.
Whatever the reason, players who rely heavily on spin will have to adjust.
I certainly did.
Power:
This is probably the Ninja’s biggest limitation.
The ball flies.
If you hit it with the same power you would use with a conventional plastic pickleball, there is a very good chance it is going long.
I discovered that quickly with my serve. My normal topspin serve simply wasn’t particularly effective with the Ninja. Between the limited spin and the ball’s tendency to carry, I had to change my approach completely.
Instead of hitting my normal aggressive topspin serve, I switched to a higher, loopier, almost lob-style serve and concentrated more on placement than power.
That worked considerably better.
Dinking, Drops and Resets:
This is where I think the Ninja shines.
Third-shot drops work well. Dinks work well. Volleys work well. Transition-zone resets work well.
In fact, because you have to take some pace off the ball and concentrate on control, the Ninja can be a very useful practice tool for the part of pickleball that many players probably need to practice the most: the soft game.
You can’t simply overpower the ball. You have to control it.
Feel:
Despite weighing only about 0.8 ounces, the Ninja has a surprisingly substantial feel when struck. It doesn’t feel like you’re hitting an extremely lightweight foam practice ball.
To me, its impact feel is closer to that of a plastic pickleball than I expected.
BOTTOM LINE
The Enhance Ninja is a very good foam practice ball, particularly if you’re willing to dial back the power.
If your objective is to practice hard drives, aggressive serves, and heavy topspin, this probably isn’t the foam ball I would choose. The ball tends to fly when hit hard, and its smooth surface makes generating significant spin difficult.
But that’s only one part of pickleball.
For third-shot drops, dinking, volleying, transition-zone resets, and general control work, the Ninja performs very well. And because those shots require you to soften your hands and concentrate on placement rather than power, the Ninja may actually be a particularly useful training ball.
It is also quiet enough to make pickleball possible in situations where hitting a conventional plastic ball might annoy the neighbors—or simply isn’t practical.
Outdoors, wind remains its biggest weakness. The Ninja can move through the air like a knuckleball, and you really have to concentrate on tracking it.
But in calm conditions—or especially indoors—I think it makes a lot of sense.
The Ninja doesn’t perfectly reproduce every aspect of a conventional pickleball. But for quiet practice, particularly the soft game, it does a very good job of reproducing the parts of pickleball that matter most.
You can purchase the balls on Amazon here: https://amzn.to/4cacD6z
You must be logged in to post a comment.